Cary, North Carolina, has quietly blossomed into a culinary hotspot, a vibrant canvas where diverse flavors come to life. And when it comes to Italian cuisine, this charming town punches well above its weight. Forget tired clichés; Cary’s Italian scene is a dynamic blend of tradition and innovation, from cozy, family-run trattorias to sleek, modern ristorantes and lively pizzerias. If you’re searching for the absolute Top Italian Restaurants in Cary NC, the kind of places where every dish tells a story and every bite transports you, you’ve come to the right guide.
As a seasoned food journalist, I’ve delved deep into Cary’s gastronomic heart, unearthing the establishments that truly master the art of Italian cooking. This isn't just a list; it’s your definitive roadmap to exceptional dining, designed to help you savor the rich tapestry of Italy right here in North Carolina.
At a Glance: Your Cary Italian Dining Guide
- Diverse Options: From elegant fine dining to casual, authentic pizzerias, Cary has an Italian spot for every occasion.
- Pasta Perfection: Discover handcrafted pasta that rivals nonna's best.
- Pizza Paradiso: Explore various styles, from Neapolitan to classic New York slices.
- Beyond the Menu: Many spots offer unique market experiences, robust wine lists, or charming outdoor seating.
- Customer Favorites: We highlight specific dishes that consistently win over local palates.
The Art of Savoring: How to Pick Your Perfect Italian Experience
Choosing an Italian restaurant isn't just about finding good food; it's about matching your mood and occasion to the right ambiance and menu. Are you looking for a romantic evening, a lively family dinner, or a quick, satisfying bite? Cary offers a spectrum of experiences, each with its own charm.
When you're ready to Find Authentic Italian in Cary, consider what matters most to you:
- Ambiance: Do you prefer white tablecloths and hushed tones, or a bustling, energetic atmosphere?
- Menu Focus: Are you craving pasta, pizza, seafood, or classic meat dishes?
- Authenticity: How traditional versus contemporary do you want the cuisine to be?
- Price Point: From budget-friendly slices to indulgent multi-course meals.
- Special Features: Outdoor dining, craft cocktails, or perhaps a market to take home fresh ingredients.
Let's dive into the restaurants that define Italian excellence in Cary.
Where Elegance Meets Italy: Cary's Premier Fine Dining Destinations
For those evenings when you want to truly treat yourself, where the service is impeccable, the wine list is thoughtful, and the food is nothing short of art, Cary offers a selection of Italian fine dining that can compete with the best. Here, the focus is on quality ingredients, sophisticated preparation, and a memorable dining experience. Looking for Carys Italian Fine Dining? These are your top contenders.
Lugano Ristorante
Address: 1060 Darrington Dr, Cary
Lugano Ristorante consistently earns accolades for its upscale ambiance and meticulously crafted Italian-American cuisine. It's the kind of place you go for a special celebration or when you simply want to indulge in refined flavors. Expect elegant plating, attentive service, and a menu that balances classic dishes with contemporary twists.
Customers' Favorites:
- White Chocolate Bread Pudding
- Espresso Chili Rubbed Filet
- Salmon & Shrimp Milanese
- Tortellini Alla Panna
- Lobster Corn Chowder
- Bruschetta Classico
- Warm Apple Crostata
- Eggplant Parmesan
- Capellini Di Mare
- Lasagna Bolognese
Colletta
Address: 1 Fenton Main St Suite 170, Cary
Nestled in the upscale Fenton development, Colletta offers a modern Italian dining experience with a vibrant, chic atmosphere. It’s perfect for a stylish date night or a sophisticated gathering with friends. Their menu features a delightful array of house-made pastas, wood-fired pizzas, and robust main courses, all executed with precision and flair.
Customers' Favorites:
- Spicy Soppressata Pizza
- Chicken Parmigiana
- Spaghetti and Sauce
- Crispy Clam Strips
- Lasagna Bolognese
- Burrata Appetizer
- Chicken Parmesan
- Marinated Olives
- Margherita Pizza
- Margarita Pizza
Enrigo Italian Bistro
Address: 575 New Waverly Pl #106, Cary
Enrigo Italian Bistro brings a touch of rustic Italian charm to Cary, without sacrificing elegance. It’s known for its authentic, from-scratch approach to Italian cooking, focusing on fresh ingredients and traditional recipes. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, making it a wonderful spot for a relaxed yet refined meal.
Customers' Favorites:
- Potato Gnocchi with Tomato Sauce
- Tasting of Panna Cotta
- Ravioli Pasticciati
- Gnocchi Bolognese
- Cannoli Siciliani
- Margherita Pizza
- Chef's Tagliolin
- Chicken Marsala
- Chicken Piccata
- Lasagna Al Ragu
Pasta Perfection & Hearty Italian Staples: Crafting Culinary Comfort
Sometimes, nothing satisfies quite like perfectly prepared pasta, rich sauces, or classic Italian comfort food. These restaurants are celebrated for their dedication to these staples, often making their pasta in-house and focusing on deeply flavorful, authentic preparations. If you’re looking for the Best pasta restaurants in Cary, these are must-tries.
La Grassa Pastificio
Address: 908 NE Maynard Rd, Cary
La Grassa Pastificio is a true gem for pasta lovers. Their name, Pastificio, means "pasta factory," and they live up to it by crafting exquisite fresh pasta daily. This commitment to handmade excellence shines through in every dish. The menu is creative yet rooted in Italian tradition, offering unique combinations and incredibly tender pasta.
Customers' Favorites:
- Rosemary Focaccia with Olive Tapenade
- Lamb with Saffron Gnocchi
- Quattro Formaggi Gnocchi
- Braised Beef Short Ribs
- Tagliatelle Bolognese
- Short Ribs and Gnocchi
- Gnocchi Ai Tartufo
- Coste Della Croce
- Eggplant Parmesan
- Veal Pappardelle
Pro's Epicurean Market & Café
Address: 211 E Chatham St, Cary
More than just a restaurant, Pro's Epicurean Market & Café is a celebration of Italian and European culinary traditions. It functions as both a gourmet market and a delightful café, offering fresh, high-quality ingredients alongside delicious prepared meals. Francesca Pro's passion for food is evident in everything they serve, from their homemade burrata to their hearty sandwiches. It's a fantastic spot for lunch or an early dinner, and you can take home some incredible ingredients too!
Customers' Favorites:
- Francesca Pro's Sausage Pie
- Cheese & Charcuterie Plates
- Fresh Homemade Burratta
- French Onion Soup
- Bruschetta Du Jour
- Rigatoni Al Ragu
- Money Sandwich
- Seafood Crape
- Chicken Parm Sandwiches
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant
Address: 1809 Walnut St, Cary
While a national chain, Olive Garden remains a go-to for many seeking familiar Italian-American comfort food in a casual, family-friendly setting. Known for its unlimited soup, salad, and breadsticks, it offers a consistent experience with a wide menu of classic pasta dishes, chicken, and seafood. It's a reliable choice when you're craving something specific and want a predictable, comforting meal.
Customers' Favorites:
- Shrimp Alfredo
- Fettuccine Alfredo Tossed with Sautéed Shrimp
- Asiago Tortelloni Alfredo with Grilled Chicken
- Never Ending Dipping Sauces for Breadsticks
- Chicken Parmigiana with Spaghetti
- Classic Shrimp Scampi Fritta
- Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo
- Chicken Marsala Fettuccine
- Chocolate Brownie Lasagna
- Chicken & Shrimp Carbonara
- Ravioli with Meat Sauce
The Pizza Powerhouses: Cary's Top Pizzerias
A great pizza is a masterpiece of simplicity: quality ingredients, a perfect crust, and a masterful hand. Cary's pizza scene is incredibly diverse, offering everything from classic New York-style slices to deep-dish delights and inventive gourmet pies. Whether you're grabbing a quick lunch or feeding the whole family, these pizzerias are top-notch.
Rigo’s Pizzeria
Address: 1260 NW Maynard Rd, Cary
Rigo’s Pizzeria is a local favorite, celebrated for its authentic New York-style pizza and a menu that’s always got something exciting. They strike a great balance between traditional pies and inventive new creations (hello, Nashville Hot Chicken Pizza!). It’s a casual, welcoming spot perfect for grabbing a slice or a whole pie.
Customers' Favorites:
- Half Cheese Half Pepperoni Pizza
- Spicy Nashville Chicken Pizza
- Nashville Hot Chicken Pizza
- Classic Margherita Pizza
- NY Style Cheese Pizza
- 2 Slices Cheese Pizza
- Steak and Cheese Sub
- Spicy Honey Pizza
- Meat Lovers Pizza
- Slice of Pizza
Salvio's Pizzeria
Address: 2428 SW Cary Pkwy, Cary
Salvio's Pizzeria is another beloved spot for classic, satisfying pizza. Known for its generous portions and consistently delicious pies, it’s a staple for many Cary residents. Their menu offers a great selection of traditional pizzas, subs, and Italian appetizers, perfect for a casual meal or takeout.
Customers' Favorites:
- Spicy Pepperoni Pizza
- Special Buffalo Chicken Pizza
- Gourmet White Pizza
- Cheese Pizza Slice
- Slice of Pizza
- Garlic Knots
- Supreme Pizza
- House Salad
- Philly Sub
- Cannoli
Johnny's Pizza (Cary)
Address: 96 Cornerstone Dr, Cary
Johnny's Pizza in Cary offers a taste of classic New York pizza with a focus on fresh ingredients and time-honored techniques. Their "Create Your Own NY Style Pizza" is a big hit, allowing you to customize your perfect pie. Beyond pizza, they also offer satisfying subs and sides.
Customers' Favorites:
- Create Your Own NY Style Pizza
- Two Slice Pepperoni Pizza
- Huge Mozzarella Sticks
- Brooklyn White Pizza
- Pepperoni Pizza Roll
- Philly Cheese Steak
- Cheese Pizza Slice
- Margherita Pizza
- Meat Lover’S
- Garlic Knots
Brothers Of New York Pizza
Address: 3450 Kildaire Farm Rd, Cary
Brothers Of New York Pizza brings that quintessential Big Apple flavor right to Cary. Known for their large, foldable slices and a classic New York vibe, they offer a wide range of pizzas from traditional pepperoni to more gourmet options. Their lunch specials are a local favorite for a quick and satisfying meal.
Customers' Favorites:
- Two Pepperoni Pizza Slices & Fountain Drink Lunch Half and Half
- Pepperoni and Sausage
- Spaghetti with Meatballs
- Chicken Parmigiana Hero
- Buffalo Chicken Pizza
- Chicken Bacon Ranch
- Eggplant Parmigiana
- Cheese Pizza Slice
- BBQ Chicken Pizza
- Prosciutto Pizza
The Original NY Pizza
Address: 6458 Tryon Rd, Cary
The Original NY Pizza is another testament to Cary’s love for classic New York-style pies. This no-frills spot focuses on delivering consistently good, authentic pizza that hits the spot every time. Whether you’re grabbing a whole pie for the family or just a slice, you can count on that familiar, delicious taste.
Customers' Favorites:
- Small Cheese Pizza
- Extra Large Pizza
- Pizza Restaurant
- Pepperoni Pizza
- Garlic Knots
- Veggie Pizza
- Small Pizza
- Greek Salad
- Calzone
- Sauce
Jet's Pizza
Address: 1253 NW Maynard Rd, Cary
Jet's Pizza stands out for its unique, Detroit-style deep-dish pizza, known for its crispy, cheesy crust and rich flavor. While they offer other styles, their deep dish is what truly sets them apart. It's a satisfying, hearty pizza experience, often customized with garlic butter crust.
Customers' Favorites:
- Extra Large Deep Dish with Garlic Butter Crust
- Half Just Cheese and Half Hamburger and Cheese
- Slice Pizza and There's a Great Lunch Special of Two Slices and a Drink for Only 4 99
- Triple Cheese Turbo Stix
- Build Your Own Pizza
- Jets-10 Well Done Pepperoni Pizza
- Boneless Wings
- 4 Corner Pizza
- Chicken Wings
- Cinnamon Stix
Bocci Trattoria & Pizzeria
Address: 2425 Kildaire Farm Rd, Cary
Bocci Trattoria & Pizzeria offers a blend of classic Italian trattoria fare and a diverse pizza menu that includes both New York and Chicago deep-dish styles. It's a versatile spot where you can enjoy a hearty pasta dish or dive into a substantial pizza, making it a great option for varied tastes within a group.
Customers' Favorites:
- Chicago Deep Dish Pizza
- Baked Lasagna Classico
- New York Style Pizza
- Chicken Parmigiana
- Nonna's Style Pizza
- Seafood Fantasia
- Bocci Balls
- Spaghetti
- Stromboli
- Calzone
Ruckus Pizza, Pasta and Spirits
Address: 8111 Tryon Woods Dr, Cary
Ruckus Pizza, Pasta and Spirits is a lively, energetic spot that combines great pizza and pasta with a fun bar atmosphere. It's known for being a local hangout, offering a broad menu that goes beyond just Italian, but their pizzas and pasta dishes are solid choices for a casual meal. It's a place where you can catch a game, enjoy a drink, and have a satisfying meal.
Customers' Favorites:
- House-Made Fried Mozzarella
- Buffalo Chicken Rangoons
- Spicy Black-Bean Wrap
- Ruckus Chopped Salad
- Huge Slice of Pizza
- Pizza by the Slice
- Ruckus Famous Tacos
- Ruckus Quesadillas
- Ruckus White Pizza
- Chicken Sandwich
Navigating the Menu: Expert Tips for an Unforgettable Meal
With so many fantastic Italian restaurants in Cary, how do you make the most of your visit? Here are a few journalist-tested tips:
- Ask the Server: Don’t hesitate to ask about daily specials or the chef’s recommendations. They often know the hidden gems on the menu.
- Embrace Appetizers: Italian dining is about sharing and savoring. Start with a bruschetta, a fresh burrata, or some fried mozzarella to get a taste of what the kitchen can do.
- Don't Skip Dessert: From creamy panna cotta to rich cannoli, Italian desserts are the perfect cap to any meal.
- Consider the Wine Pairing: Many Italian dishes truly sing when paired with the right wine. Ask for recommendations that complement your chosen meal.
- Check for Lunch Specials: Many pizzerias and bistros offer excellent lunch deals, perfect for sampling without committing to a full dinner price.
Your Next Italian Adventure Awaits
Cary, NC, is a treasure trove for Italian food lovers. Whether you're seeking a sophisticated dining experience, a plate of handcrafted pasta, or a perfectly charred pizza, this guide provides a starting point for your culinary explorations. Each of these restaurants brings something unique to the table, united by a shared passion for the flavors and traditions of Italy.
So, gather your loved ones, decide on your craving, and get ready to indulge. Buon appetito!